Jackson Free Press

Predictably, Sheriff Malcolm McMillin won the right to keep his site over challengers tonight, including Mayor Frank Melton's choice, police spokesman Tyrone Lewis. WAPT guest political analyst Matt Friedeman summed it up well: "Mayor Melton is a loser tonight."

Melton also did not win the district attorney's seat, with incumbent Faye Peterson leading Robert Smith, and then Michele Purvis. A runoff is likely in that race, and that was also predictable.

Previous Comments

ID

94277

Comment

Congrats to Mac!

Author

LatashaWillis

Date

2007-08-07T22:29:22-06:00

ID

94278

Comment

this one's good!

Author

pikersam

Date

2007-08-07T22:42:10-06:00

ID

94279

Comment

Just clicked on the link. Ewwwww.

Author

LatashaWillis

Date

2007-08-07T22:49:56-06:00

ID

94280

Comment

At nearly 1 a.m. Eastern time, The Clarion-Ledger is right on top of things per usual with their top candidate headline: McMillin leading in Hinds sheriff race Snirk. They really shouldn't try this live blogging thang. Play to your strengths. Lead with Bonds.

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-07T23:00:50-06:00

ID

94281

Comment

Did anyone see when one of the news channels did a sweep of the Lewis victory party around 8:15 and there were exactly 7 people there? WOW talk about embarrassing. Also, what a cruel camera man. I think he needs an emmy, an oscar or whatever award is open. I certainly will buy him a round

Author

AGamm627

Date

2007-08-07T23:02:27-06:00

ID

94282

Comment

I just submitted a Bonds thread. How long before it is approved?

Author

pikersam

Date

2007-08-07T23:07:46-06:00

ID

94283

Comment

Pike, I like this one. AGamm, I saw that. Yikes.

Author

LatashaWillis

Date

2007-08-07T23:10:15-06:00

ID

94284

Comment

I also think that Lewis' DJ should have known better than to play "Shake You Down" and "Sexual Healing" at an event like that.

Author

LatashaWillis

Date

2007-08-07T23:12:25-06:00

ID

94285

Comment

I love political cartoons!

Author

pikersam

Date

2007-08-07T23:12:50-06:00

ID

94286

Comment

I'll look at it, Pike, now. Sorry—we've had to turn on more controls of late for obvious reasons.

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-07T23:16:34-06:00

ID

94287

Comment

I agree with Matt Friedman from channel 16 ..Mayor Frank Melton...lost tonigt. I am so excited that McMillin was reelected....

Author

blkokc

Date

2007-08-08T01:54:43-06:00

ID

94288

Comment

OK, folks, now that the dust is clearing, we will get the campaign finance reports of the three D.A. candidates up and analyzed. (Purvis' will still be interesting, considering how close she and Smith have been as recently as January.) We'll also parse the the numbers in Hinds County to see what happened where. It's going to be interesting to figure out where the support base is for the two surviving candidates. We'll also see if we can put together a real debate between Peterson and Smith between now and the runoff, and we will invite them both back on the radio show again. It's really time to get in there and get as specific as possible. If Smith is going to make a serious bid for this office, he needs to win on his merits and something more substantive than "respect" and the fact that he has an impressive family history. We need to do a good, in-depth profile of Smith to stand next to all the coverage we've done on Peterson over the years. Let's figure out what makes him tick.

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-08T07:22:32-06:00

ID

94289

Comment

If it ain't broke what's left to fix.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T07:47:28-06:00

ID

94290

Comment

In other words, McMillan shouldn't have been challenged.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T07:49:02-06:00

ID

94291

Comment

I think one of the most important things we need is a list of criminals that Smith has represented. Not just Recio, and the other few Melton cases. But, like the guy that robbed Hal and Mal's. Where does a petty criminal reduced to holding up a restaurant get money to afford a high powered defense attorney? Has he represented anyone who has committed crimes against elderly? Children? He's supposedly good at his job? How many were let off just because of one or two jurors? If the person is innocent, they are innocent. But, you have to figure he's tried some cases much like the recent Brunner case were one juror wavered, and they had to retry him. Then we need to see if Smith has worked with Ali Shamsadeen and Priester. What cases, what happened, etc. That would be 3 defense attorneys that Melton will have in key positions in the justice system. I think the Michael Taylor fiasco this past June is proof enough that Melton is meddling in the Municipal Justice Court though Shamsadeen and Priester. People have to look at the whole picture and realize that you can't have it both ways. Saying you are voting for Sheriff Mac because of Melton, and then handing him (and his old white cronies Ed Peter's and Danks) the DA's office is absurd and goes against conventional wisdom.

Author

pikersam

Date

2007-08-08T07:49:25-06:00

ID

94292

Comment

Robert and Faye have neutralized/paralyzed me. I like both equally. Though I would like to see Faye keep the seat because I think she has been treated unfairly (not by Robert so far), I won't publicly choose between them. This makes me a wussy. So be it.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T07:54:31-06:00

ID

94293

Comment

Ray, the unfair treatment will begin by this afternoon. However, he should tread carefully. She has all the records on all the cases she should begin to release to the media so we can see how many repeat offenders he has gotten off.

Author

pikersam

Date

2007-08-08T08:01:53-06:00

ID

94294

Comment

Where is Michelle Purvis? Enough (hiding) is enough!

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T09:36:39-06:00

ID

94295

Comment

Go Faye!!!

Author

dpsmith

Date

2007-08-08T13:33:40-06:00

ID

94296

Comment

Ray, there is only one "L" in Michele. Ms. Purvis is very sensitive about the spelling of her name. "ONE (L) IS ENOUGH!!" LMAO

Author

thetruth

Date

2007-08-08T16:04:30-06:00

ID

94297

Comment

Pike, Channel 16 just reported a few minutes ago that Peterson said what Hinds County doesn't needs is someone who is in bed with the criminals. She also said she's the candidate who has prosecuted criminals and Smith hasn't. I like the comments alright except for accusing him of being in bed with criminals since she was a public defender too once upon a time. Robert cooly, in my view, responded by saying he knows how to do the job and Faye was a public defender who used to work with him. I don't want to see this race get relegated to who can make the most counter-accusations. I believe the winner will be the person who performs the best during the next 2 to 3 weeks. Personally, I wouldn't attack, and instead would just tell the voters what I would do if elected and why I believe I can do it better than my opponent. That bed comment by Peterson is a dangerous one to make under the circumstances. I hope Robert will continue to act as a gentlemen.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T16:16:43-06:00

ID

94298

Comment

Thanks, Truth. I'll try to do better. I got fired once for my spelling and still haven't learned.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T16:19:20-06:00

ID

94299

Comment

I don't know if that was smart on Peterson's part, Ray, either. But isn't being a public defender rather different than being a high-priced defense attorney?

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-08T16:23:37-06:00

ID

94300

Comment

In my opinion a very good defense or prosecuting attorney would be able to do either job well, eventually, but maybe not instantly. A good attorney anticipates and appreciates the tactics, strengths, maneuvers and weaknesses of their opponents arsenal and case, as well as know how to present their case effectively, despite the challenges and pitfalls that will occurr during trials. Smith has to be able to do these things pretty well otherwise he wouldn't be called a successful attorney and paid like one since he try cases and is not a mere plea king. And he wouldn't have been winning so much if not talented. Faye likely has an advantage which I can't measure as of right now because she has been doing the job for years. Robert remains an able attorney no matter the fumbling with papers everone saw on television or personaly during Melton's trial. I can't remember exactly what Truth said earlier when this question was posed once before, but I remember he or she gave an excellent response to the differences between the two jobs. If Robert wins he will have to hire a staff and get ready to prosecute wheras Faye want have any such problems. My bet is that if Robert wins he can keep the staff Faye has if he wanted them. They don't want to go looking for a job.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-08T16:42:50-06:00

ID

94301

Comment

Two things Ray. Personally, I wouldn't attack, and instead would just tell the voters what I would do if elected and why I believe I can do it better than my opponent. Ray They told Johnson to do the same... And he did. See where that got him? Being the 'good guy' when you are running against a snake will only get you bit. Johnson had plenty of Melton negatives he could have used that he didn't. If anyone is qualified to say whether Robert represents 'criminals' or not it is Faye. She knows the cases. However you are right, Roberts response was good, if you are trying to get the vote of people who have relatives and friends who are in the 'system.' :-/ My bet is that if Robert wins he can keep the staff Faye has if he wanted them. They don't want to go looking for a job. Ray Again, I disagree. How many people are left who once worked for Johnson? Musgrove? Chief Moore?

Author

pikersam

Date

2007-08-08T17:23:59-06:00

ID

94302

Comment

I just heard Robert Smith say on WAPT of Peterson: "She is not involved in trying cases." Huh? Is he now going to become Michele Purvis and just start making crap up??? Also, I don't get responding to her point about him defending rich alleged criminals for pay with saying that she was once a public defender, too. That's just not the same thing. He's not still a public defender. If he were, he wouldn't be defending Albert Donelson's friends. Or Marcus Wright, for that matter. Or Michael Taylor. Or Darnell Turner. These guys don't use public defenders. There's a way to defend what she said, I presume, but that ain't it.

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-08T17:28:45-06:00

ID

94303

Comment

Folks, RIGHT NOW (at 7:34 PM Eastern time on WEDNESDAY), this is the lead news blurb on The Clarion-Ledger's Web site: Peterson, Smith neck and neck in DA's race Hinds County District Attorney Faye Peterson and challenger Robert Shuler Smith appeared headed for a runoff Tuesday night. Is the mothership completely lost here? Their election coverage has been a half day behind the whole time. They need to give up the liveblogging idea and go back to reporting 101.

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-08T17:35:12-06:00

ID

94304

Comment

Peterson, Smith neck and neck in DA's race Where have I heard that phrase "neck and neck" before? It's not a phrase used often to describe, er...horse races, is it? Are they a high school newspaper? (I mean no disrespect to high school newspapers.) Is there NOTHING they could write to ADD SOMETHING to their voter's understanding of a political decision they need to make? Although, to be fair to the C-L staff who have to stay up and deal with these political races, they don't get free coffee anymore in order to keep the profits at 25%. So, you know, it's tough to be on your game late at night. (Here's a fascinating piece on horse race coverage, by the way.)

Author

Todd Stauffer

Date

2007-08-08T19:08:06-06:00

ID

94305

Comment

Vote Faye Peterson for District Attorney.

Author

dpsmith

Date

2007-08-08T19:47:18-06:00

ID

94306

Comment

dp, no one is going to accuse you of not trying. ;-)

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-08T20:04:34-06:00

ID

94307

Comment

I only had a problem with the "bed" part of the comment by Faye. My fighting spirit and quick wit would have gotten great, even if having to get low down, mileage out of that comment, if you know what I mean. I was perfectly alright for her to say he represents criminals. In bed with them is a different allegation. Robert is naturally a good person who was reared by lots of strong and respectful relatives, men and women. Good for him. Other than that comment I think both are doing well, and I wish both the best. You can represent criminals and not be in bed with them. Johnnie Cochran and many other fine criminal lawyers have done it for years. That why Johnnie turned down $600,000.00 handed to him that he hadn't earned. I represent people acused of capital murders, yet my co-workers would likely tell you I'm not against the death penalty and am not too crazy about people who commit crimes. However, I also believe my co-workers will say they know few people who will fight as hard as I will to free and make sure an alleged criminal gets justice from the system. I understand the role I play in the criminal defense process. I would likely be just as focused and dtermined if on the other side. In fairness to Robert I know he understands this concept too.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-09T09:11:10-06:00

ID

94308

Comment

I started a Truthwatch thread about the "in bed with" accusation. Let's use it to jumpstart more discussion.

Author

DonnaLadd

Date

2007-08-09T09:22:11-06:00

ID

94309

Comment

First off let me say that Tyrone Lewis should have known better than to go up against Boss Hogg -- Sheriff McMillin. We love McMillin. And he may be the last high ranking law officer who still believes in "law enforcement values." Now, ladd, you made me blush (do men blush?) but I am praying that the city of Jackson doesn't make the grave mistake of putting Robert Shuler Smith in the seat of District Attorney. Faye Peterson is the more solid choice.

Author

dpsmith

Date

2007-08-09T18:19:28-06:00

ID

94310

Comment

I'm voting Faye Peterson because she can be trusted to do the work for the citizen of Jackson and not for Frank Melton and his group. Robert if he had any sense would know that Frank if he is elected will come to collect. The good person that he might be is somewhat slow if he can't figure out that he is beign set-up by the good old boys and will be just like the chief of police, a house boy. I've actually seen him in a court room and thought that if he was my attorney, I would have slapped him. He on the slow bus. I'm voting for someone who want sell our or be rented out, the oath that Faye took she stands behind it and represents the people of Jackson. I understand that Ed Peters is rich; I wonder how did this happen, the job now pays maybe $96,000 and wasn't this amount when he was there for over 30 years. My question to the readers where did he get the money....could it have been under the table payoff for the rich kids?

Author

BJM

Date

2007-08-10T18:38:57-06:00

ID

94311

Comment

I'm voting Faye Peterson because she can be trusted to do the work for the citizen of Jackson and not for Frank Melton and his group. Robert if he had any sense would know that Frank if he is elected will come to collect and undress him if he is not his lap dog. The good person that he might be is somewhat slow if he can't figure out that he is beign set-up by the good old boys and will be just like the chief of police, a house boy. I've actually seen him in a court room and thought that if he was my attorney, I would have slapped him. He is on the slow bus and not quick. I'm voting for someone who want sell out or be rented, the oath that Faye took she stands behind it and represents the people of Jackson. I understand that Ed Peters is rich; I wonder how did this happen, the job now pays maybe $96,000 and wasn't this amount when he was there for over 30 years. My question to the readers where did he get the money....could it have been under the table payoff for the rich kids? You know a lot of the negative toward our current DA is because she is a woman and not because of her skills. The women should be angry for the type of treatment and stand up in her defense. It goes to say that we as black people will never progress because we are always jealous, fail to stay inform and just believe everything the media writes or states. Melton is sorry and loves to pick on women. So for me anyone with any association with this man, I would never vote for or respect.

Author

BJM

Date

2007-08-10T18:47:07-06:00

ID

94312

Comment

Ray, I understand that you have known Robert Smith for quite a while. Perhaps you guys may have even attended college together. But how much have you hung out with him recently? You have to realize that people change as they grow older and gain acquaintances or reacquaint themselves with less than admirable high school friends. I understand that defense attorney's by virtue of their profession have to communicate with gentlemen that are not the pillars of the community, but usually this communication is mainly in a professional setting. My problem with Smith is that he also hangs out with these same "alleged" drug dealers & murderers socially. I don't think you would be caught dead with these type of people outside of your professional life. These are the associations that bother me.

Author

thetruth

Date

2007-08-11T13:26:53-06:00

ID

94313

Comment

Sorry meant to say "defense attorneys"

Author

thetruth

Date

2007-08-11T13:28:13-06:00

ID

94314

Comment

I would be surprised to learn Robert is doing anything unsavory. I'm much older than he is, and I never saw a single sign that he would knowingly put himself in a bad place or position.

Author

Ray Carter

Date

2007-08-13T07:50:36-06:00

ID

94315

Comment

By the way, where is frank melton? He has been as quiet as a church mouse.

Author

justjess

Date

2007-08-13T09:01:07-06:00